Wednesday, July 16, 2014

$500 layout

I may have mentioned that I got interested in a contest, unfortunately I missed the deadline but I've been having fun with the premise anyway.

The idea is to create a fully functional layout including benchwork, trackage, locomotives, rolling stock, scenery and control systems for less than $500. This is, of course, a beginners layout, so nothing fancy.

I bid on and won a LifeLike CB&Q train set that had an SD7 locomotive and a handful of cars. The CB&Q used to run through my little hometown, so that pretty much sealed the deal.

I have operating trackwork and control systems on my benchwork, and now I'm down to scenery. All told so far I have spent about half of the allotted funds.

The track plan is below:


Clockwise from the left we have the brick passenger station, which still exists and will have to be scratchbuilt (the picture would have been taken from across the tracks). Next is Lisle's Tools, an extant company that is currently the town's largest employer. Since the tracks are gone now they ship by truck, but they used to ship materials in and finished product out. Next is a scrapyard that handled the waste from the tool company. The next block is filled with industrial buildings that were never served by the railroad and now are part of the Lisle's complex. Next is the freight station, also still extant (the picture is taken from the south looking north, the tracks would have been on the right side of the station), and the Purina grain elevator, likewise still there and shipping by truck.

After that I've cut a lot of the town out and then I added a stockyard just beyond the meat packing plant, these two industries take the sidings at the far right. The Wilson's meat processing plant is long gone and the stockyard never existed (the meat processing plant took in frozen carcasses and output finished packaged products), but it seemed like a good idea to have them together and gave me a reason to use the stock car that was packaged with the train set.

The prototype entered town on the north side just east of 8th Street, continuing on a south-southwesterly heading in more or less a straight line, exiting across Highway 2/71 bypass about midway between 12th and 8th Streets. You can see on the map how 8th Street runs at a diagonal to follow the right of way between Garfield (just across the street from the freight station) and Cross Street.

The rails also ran along the east side of 8th Street through Miller Oil and the warehouses across the street from the grain elevator down to a furniture store that was in the building now housing Barker Implement. Another spur ran through the middle of the junkyard to a Co-Op grain elevator that used to stand across 5th Street from the auction house.

The layout encompasses the areas between Washington and 8th (where the passenger station still stands) to just beyond Garfield and 8th (the Purina grain elevators). The meat packing plant was south of town near the airport and has long since been shut down, although I believe the building still stands.

The prototype track continued to points south and west, but by the time the CB&Q became part of the Burlington Northern system the tracks were being pulled up. The trackage was still there through little Shambaugh, Iowa when I was in high school, but by the time I left for the Navy the tracks ended just south of town. This branch has been pulled up now all the way back to the mainline in Villisca, Iowa and is no more.

Rolling stock consists of a red and silver CB&Q SD7 locomotive, two stock cars, two reefers, two covered hoppers, two gondolas, two boxcars and a silver CB&Q caboose. Operation is simple, the train with the following consist enters from the north side of town: locomotive, covered hopper, reefer, stock car, gondola and boxcar, trailed by the caboose.

The caboose is dropped at the passenger station and the rest of the train is pulled up through the passing siding. The boxcar is switched out for one on the spur at Lisle's and the full car is pushed back to the caboose. The gondola on the scrapyard spur is likewise switched out and the full car goes back with the caboose. Now the last three cars are spotted on the passing siding while the loco does a run-around.

The covered hopper is switched out with the full car going to the main briefly so the empty can be spotted. The full car is then picked up and left on the passing siding as the loco, reefer and stock car back out to the main. The loco then pushes the stock car and reefer to their respective spurs, picking up the empty stock car and full reefer and leaving them on the main while it drops off the new cars.

The full reefer and  empty stock car are then pulled back along the main and pushed up into place behind the full covered hopper that was previously left on the siding. The loco runs around again and pushes these three cars back to connect to the gondola, box car and caboose. This whole consist goes to the mainline while the locomotive runs around the siding, spots the caboose on the siding, then connects and pulls the train back north. Back into the siding to connect to the caboose, and away she goes back to the off-scene mainline connection in Villisca.

I have since put another siding along the back stretch so that the loco and caboose can be switched back for another run through town. This also affords the opportunity to run a passenger consist through town while the freight is out of the picture.

The trackwork is solid and works well, the benchwork consists of two 2x4 foot tables that connect together in the middle. The control system, such as it is, consists of the train set power pack, Atlas slide switches for powering the track sections, and manual turnouts along the front with remote turnouts on the back siding. All track including turnouts is Atlas Code 80. The end curves are snap track 11" radius; if I were to do it all over again I'd use the 19" curves from the turnouts at each end and a 9 1/2" section in the middle to give some easement without having to expand the depth of the layout. At any rate I'm happy with it so far, and it gives me something to run on while I disassemble the large 4x8 that I had set up previously.

Friday, June 27, 2014

Back It Up

The Bachmann 4-4-0 conversion I have never did want to back up. Any attempt to reverse this loco would cause the locomotive to roll over and fall off the tracks.

I finally figured out what the problem was. I have a non-Bachmann screw in the loco to tender connection because I lost the original and couldn't find a replacement. The problem was the original screw was shouldered and the replacement was not.

The tender connection is a large open loop that goes around the screw. With the standard shouldered screw the shoulder fills this hole pretty well, with the replacement, not so much. So, when the loco would back into the tender it would get close enough that the driveshaft would bind against the loco body and tip it over.

I filled the tender loop with a piece of scrap styrene, drilled a smaller hole for the screw, and just like magic the problem is solved and the loco will back happily around the layout with it's train preceding it, no problems at all.

I only wish my standard gauged Bachmann 4-4-0's ran this well.

Wednesday, May 7, 2014

MP part 2

I just got in the other Pacific I ordered, from another vendor.

I have to take the tender apart tomorrow to repair the drawbar connection. Just as well I suppose since I have to replace the coupler anyway.

I am now 3 for 3 on Model Power Pacifics, I have three and none of them were ready to run when I got them. The first one was from a private owner, so I bought someone elses problem, but the last two were straight from dealers stock.

My statements concerning Model Power still stand.

Friday, May 2, 2014

Model Power

The buzz is all about Model Power going out of business. I've seen on the trainboards and such all sorts of excuses and blame passed around; some say the banks, some say the business practices, some say suppliers, a soft market, etc etc etc, but I can say I know exactly what it was...hit or miss product and poor to non-existent quality control.

I have two MP Pacifics (and one on the way) and so far neither one of them have been good performers out of the box. The only reason I even have them is because they are the only manufacturer that currently offers a USRA Pacific, and now that they are gone it leaves a hole in the N scale steam lineup.

The first one, which now serves as spare parts for the other two, had a gear train that never did mesh correctly and no amount of tweaking and tuning would ever make the motor gear stay in contact with the drive gear. I tried several times before giving it up as a bad idea; taking the darn thing apart is an exercise in frustration, every time you move something you pull another wire loose and the running gear has been accurately described as a "Chinese puzzle box" which, if you ever need to take it apart, is almost impossible to put back together.

The second one, which arrived just this afternoon, looked great but as soon as I took it out of the box I found the drawbar was disconnected from the tender. It is usually held on by a plastic stud that is melted down to hold the drawbar, the mushroomed end had broken off of the stud and there wasn't enough left of it to reconnect the drawbar. So, I had to take the tender shell off, dig around in my parts box to find a suitable screw, drill a hole and reattach the drawbar. In the meantime the smokebox front fell off and had to be glued back on, and of course one of the wires broke loose in the tender and had to be reconnected. This was, I reiterate, a brand new right out of the box locomotive; besides the hobby shop I purchased it from I am the first and only owner of said loco.

I also purchased a Model Power Mikado, mostly to compare it to the Kato and Atlas locos, and it was a good trouble-free runner right out of the box. Spookshow says the Mikado suffers from the same QC issues as the Pacific so it looks like I just lucked out and got a good one. The gold standard for Mikados continues to be the now-discontinued Kato of course, hopefully they will resume production for at least another run or two sometime in the future. I have two of the Katos, one with the GHQ Pennsylvania L1 conversion (and the other one will get it as soon as I get around to it), and they are phenomenal runners; all the hype is true.

One last thing...Rapido couplers with no knuckle coupler offered? Seriously? In this day and age?

So to recap - hit or miss products, seemingly non-existent quality control, and little to no apparent effort to improve either one. Bachmann, on the other hand, has steadily improved in both quality of product and consistency. If you would like to see how to do it...or how not to...these two companies are good (and bad) examples to follow. Yeah, good riddance Model Power.

It sure would be nice to have a quality Pacific from Bachmann or Kato, the Bachmann Spectrum line would benefit from another offering and Kato already makes a suitable chassis for it in their JNR models. For that matter, whoever owns the toolings now from the old Ted Brandon designed Rivarrosi Mikado and Pacific steamers that have been distributed by Atlas and ConCor, now would be a good time to bring both of them back with improved materials for the frames and better motors, maybe gearmotors to improve the low speed performance. One can dream at least.

And finally, for those of us who have been in N scale for a while, how odd is it to say "Gosh, I wish Bachmann would make a 4-6-2 steam locomotive!"

Thursday, November 7, 2013

EBT M-1?

Roy Stevens on the Nn3 list has been busy creating Nn3 items in his Shapeways shop. Unfortunately many of his creations are un-printable due to resolution issues for these small items, but I have gotten copies of the things I have been able to.

One of those things that I have often wished for was the East Broad Top's M-1 gas electric motor car.

Looks like I'm getting my wish!

It is printing now, when it gets here I'll do a build post.

Pinky swear!

Wednesday, July 31, 2013

Projects

Today in the mail I got these:

I've already made one of these, so I'll use them to make one of these.

That's the only drawback of modeling the East Broad Top in Nn3, you have to make your own passenger cars, but then again that's where the fun is.

Friday, February 15, 2013

Dreams Coming True?

I am of the firm opinion that one of the best things to happen to model railroading is 3D printing. Using 3D printing we have access to make a lot of things at a reasonable cost, and one of the things I have always wanted was a model of the East Broad Top's gas-electric railcar M-1 in Nn3. So far as I know there is only one hand-built example in existence, and I don't have the confidence in my abilities to make another one.

With the advent of 3D printing the only thing that needs to be done is create a CAD model to fit over a prime mover. Searails has recently introduced a power truck that would be perfect for the project that is now sold through RLW, and I have been working at getting the information to the 3D modeler that created the EBT 2 and 3 bay hoppers that I built earlier. Now that he has it, he is hard at work in the creative process.

Maybe soon I'll have my very own M-1 roaming my narrow gauge rails. I suppose I'd better get started on getting them done. Towards that end my Clover House wide tie strips have arrived, so when I get the chance (between Mustang activities and finally completing my associates degree) I'll get the turnouts fixed and maybe try to mount one. I have an idea that I can mount the turnout on a piece of basswood for stability and then use a Caboose ground throw to actuate it, but I'll have to make a spring arrangement to keep from over-extending the throwbar and breaking the points loose from it. The trick will be getting a thin enough basswood piece to blend in with the cork roadbed and yet have it strong enough to hold everything in place. I might end up using birch instead, I'll have to see what is available. The second challenge will be getting everything fastened down securely and permanently enough to work full time, I have a feeling I would be better served to fasten the PC ties down rather than rely solely on the Pliobonded wood ties.

After the trackwork has been completed I'll get some foam and finally get serious about learning how to do scenery. It should be fun!